Book Review of “Why the End is not Near: A Refutation of End-Times Hysteria”

9780975391464Why the End is Not Near! This is the emphatic declaration made by Duane Garner, Associate Pastor of Auburn Avenue Presbyterian in Monroe, LA. It is certainly a bold statement to make in light of the current majority opinion. If you are looking for a concise book to be read in sixty minutes defining and describing the eschatological system known as Dispensationalism, look no further! Duane has summarized the strange history of Dispensationalism beginning with a dream, then to Darby, and  Scofield.

The book presents an alternative. Pastor Garner offers an explicitly biblical response to this dangerous eschatology that has paralyzed the modern church. This alternative is an optimistic view of the future based on the promises of Yahweh throughout Redemptive History and fulfilled in the Messiah, the Christ, who ushered His Kingdom in the first century.

What’s unique about it?

There have been many large books refuting Dispensationalism; John Gerstner and Kenneth Gentry come to mind. However, their works are large tomes for the seminary student or the curious layman who has at least eight hours to invest, and further, it assumes certain knowledge of the subject. Helpful and extraordinarily insightful as they may be, these books are not for the simple. Duane’s book is for the layman who is new to the Reformation faith and stumbled upon this controversy he never knew existed. As Garner points in the book, there are some out there who believe that there are no other alternatives to the Rapture frenzy.

The other uniqueness of this book is that it touches on the political consequences of an eschatology of defeat. Pastor Garner pursues vociferously the inconsistencies of Dispensational advocates. On the one hand, they cry out for political justice. On the other hand, they are prophesying the doom of the land; a retreatist posture.

What is Dispensationalism?

Dispensationalism, as the author describes, “… is a system defined largely by its view of the end of the world and can hardly be described apart from it.” (15) With such a defined pessimistic worldview, one wonders what keeps them from selling all they have. Actually some have! Fortunately, the majority do not live consistently with their basic premise.

What’s so popular about this System?

Many have discovered the inherent flaws of this system. Their abuse of passages like Matthew 24 and Revelation are so blatant that it is hard to treat it with any seriousness. Yet, they enjoy the majority of popularity in this country. Michael Horton once wrote that every American has at one time been a “Teenage Dispensationalist.” The story goes that as they come to greater understanding they quickly move away from it. Dispensationalism is a distinctly American eschatology. Garner writes:

The popularity of the doctrine has permeated popular Christian thought so completely that an entire generation of evangelicals and fundamentalists is not even aware of any other way of reading the Bible, and is entirely unfamiliar with any opposing view of eschatology. (17)

The system boasts of some mighty eloquent and persuasive proponents. This may explain much of the popularity. Our only hope is that this small book will spark the interest of some to re-consider their position. Hal Lindsey’s books have made millions, but it has also deceived millions. How much false prophecy makes a false prophet? If this question were taken seriously, the answer would emerge forcefully. But people are merciful, and as long as an ideology fits their imaginative criteria, there is no such thing as a wrong theory.

Conclusion

Garner offers an eschatology of hope and not of fear; an eschatology that is not dependent on newspaper exegesis, but on the text of Scripture. The Psalms declare that the glory of God will cover the earth in time and history. This vision of the progressive increase of the glory of God throughout the nations is what led to the great missionary revivals of past centuries. It was the answer then, and it is still the only answer now. As Garner concludes:

Only with an understanding that the kingdom will one day cover the earth can the church consistently take on any task that will have any lasting value. (57)

About these ads

About Uri Brito

I am the Pastor of Providence Church (CREC) in Pensacola, Fl.
This entry was posted in Book Reviews, Eschatology. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Book Review of “Why the End is not Near: A Refutation of End-Times Hysteria”

  1. Nigel says:

    For the long-covered-up skinny on the 179-year-old, fringe-British-invented pretribulation rapture theory, Google “Pretrib Rapture Diehards,” “X-Raying Margaret,” “Pretrib Hypocrisy,” “America’s Pretrib Rapture Traffickers,” and “Pretrib Rapture Dishonesty” – all by journalist/historian Dave MacPherson who has actually focused for 40 years on the same theory and who keeps discovering more fascinating details and turning out more books on it, the most comprehensive of which is his 300-pager titled “The Rapture Plot” (see Armageddon Books). He offers evidence that the theory is anti-Jewish, anti-Catholic, and anti-mainline Protestant – and he has traced it back to a young woman in Scotland in 1830. He and his wife discovered faded handwritten records there which made waves at the time but were soon forgotten and covered up for many decades. Interestingly, not until C. I. Scofield plagiarized the same escapist theory, which turned up in the marginal notes in his 1909 Bible, did the theory become an important belief in American evangelicalism. That’s how new the pretrib rapture really is in the history of Christianity! Nigel

  2. Bart says:

    MacPherson has also written “Edward Irving is Unnerving” on Google. Dispensationalism can no longer plead ignorance! Bart

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s